U.S. Supreme Court Reverses L.A. Man's Murder Conviction
The 6th Amendment to the US Constitution guarantees the right of the accused in a criminal prosecution to confront those witnesses against him/her. However, in a disturbing trend, prosecutors throughout the nation, have been using prior police report statements to assist their prosecution where the witness is unavailable, or refuses, to testify against the accused at trial. http://www.latimes.com/news/local/la-na-giles26-2008jun26,0,7381319.story
The US Supreme Court today reversed a Los Angeles man's murder conviction, by ruling that no exception to the confrontation clause existed in his case. Dwayne Giles was accused of murder after he admittedly shot his girlfriend six times at his residence. He and his criminal defense attorney claimed self-defense. To attack his self-defense claim, prosecutors used the testimony from police officers who stated they had previou